Tree Protection Bylaw update
A $40,000 update of the Town's tree bylaw, with public input. It was moved twice: from 2025 to 2026, then to 2027.
- Amount
- $40,000
- Got
- $0
- Where it stands
- To 2027. Moved twice: 2025 to 2026 by the Eaglecrest funding plan, then to 2027 in Dec 2025 citing Eaglecrest workload (4–1, Skipsey opposed). How Eaglecrest was paid for.
What it is
Tree Protection Bylaw No. 725 was adopted in March 2023. It requires a permit to remove protected trees. It protects trees 30 cm or more across at chest height, plus some special species.
On a residential lot with a house, the owner can remove one protected tree every two calendar years without a permit. That doesn't apply to Garry Oak, Arbutus, Pacific Yew or Pacific Dogwood, to trees 75 cm or more across, or to trees in hazard or ecological permit areas. The bylaw also allows a permit for a tree that is a fire hazard to property.
Each permit requires two replacement trees for every tree cut. Instead, the owner can pay the Town $1,000 per replacement tree to plant them elsewhere in town.
This $40,000 project would hire a consultant to consult the public, do research and update the bylaw.
Council scheduled it for 2025. It was then moved twice. On July 23, 2025, the Eaglecrest funding plan moved it to 2026. On December 17, 2025, Council moved it to 2027.
What happened
- March 22, 2023At first reading, Council added a direction to staff to run a comprehensive public engagement process on the bylaw and bring back an updated schedule within a year (Councillor Skipsey's amendment; Councillor Harrison opposed).
- March 24, 2023Council adopted Tree Protection Bylaw No. 725. Staff later said the public engagement work was delayed by zoning changes required by the Province.
- October 21, 2024Staff recommended keeping the update in 2028 at $20,000, because of workload. A residents' association asked for it sooner.
- November 1, 2024The committee recommended $40,000 in 2025 for a consultant-led update. Councillor Young opposed. Council adopted this on December 11, 2024.
- March 12, 2025The owner of 2150 Island Highway West appealed the conditions on a permit to remove 121 trees for a five-lot subdivision. The bylaw required 242 replacement trees, or $242,000 instead. Staff recommended waiving the whole amount. Councillor Harrison moved the waiver and Mayor Westbroek seconded it, but the motion was withdrawn. Council instead cut the payment to the value of the timber being removed (4–1, Councillor Skipsey opposed).
- July 23, 2025The Eaglecrest funding plan moved the update from 2025 to 2026 (4–1, Councillor Harrison opposed).
- December 17, 2025Council moved it from 2026 to 2027, citing Planning Department workload from Eaglecrest. The vote was 4–1, with Councillor Skipsey opposed.
- September 9, 2026Councillor Vander Valk moved a motion on replacement trees and permits. Council referred it to the 2027 strategic planning session.
Why it matters
- The December 2025 motion said the Planning Department is "at maximum staff capacity for 2026" because of the Eaglecrest lands.
- Before fall 2024, the update was planned for 2028. Council moved it up to 2025, so 2027 is still earlier than that first plan.
- The September 2026 motion said the bylaw was not scheduled for review until 2028. The staff comment and budget documents show 2027.
- The same motion said the Town has not yet planted replacement trees paid for by cash in lieu. That is a councillor's statement, not a staff finding. The Town's Tree Replacement Reserve held $33,000 at the end of 2025, up from $30,200 a year earlier and $10,000 at the end of 2022. The 2026–2030 Financial Plan shows none of it being spent through 2030.
- Not all of the reserve is cash in lieu. The Town's 2025 budget also paid into it. In February 2023, before this bylaw was adopted, Council gave up to $5,000 from the reserve to the Memorial golf course for tree planting.
- The bylaw gives owners 90 days from the permit to plant their replacement trees when no construction is planned. It sets no deadline for the Town to plant trees paid for with cash in lieu. The September 2026 motion mentions an 18-month timeframe in the bylaw. We didn't find one.
- On 2150 Island Highway West, staff wrote that the trees stood in the subdivision's road and service corridors and that there was "no viable way to preserve the trees" while using the land as zoned. The bylaw doesn't let staff change a permit's conditions, so the decision went to Council. Residents sent four letters about the tree removal in the three days before the meeting. The Town logged one of them as "Opposed To Waiving Fee For Developer."
- In 2024, a residents' association told Council that the bylaw does not apply to Town-owned land.
Sources
- Special Council minutes, Dec 17, 2025 (opens in a new tab)
- Special Council minutes, Jul 23, 2025 (opens in a new tab)
- Special Council agenda and deferral lists, Jul 23, 2025 (opens in a new tab) p. 6 (resolution item 3)
- Staff report: 2025–2029 Financial Plan Amendment, Oct 22, 2025 (opens in a new tab) p. 14
- Committee of the Whole agenda, Oct 21, 2024 (scoping sheet) (opens in a new tab) pp. 15–16
- Committee of the Whole minutes, Oct 21, 2024 (opens in a new tab) p. 2
- Committee of the Whole minutes, Nov 1, 2024 (opens in a new tab) p. 1
- Regular Council minutes, Dec 11, 2024 (opens in a new tab) p. 7
- Regular Council agenda, Sep 9, 2026 (opens in a new tab) p. 8
- Council Corner, Sep 9, 2026 (opens in a new tab) p. 2
- 2026–2030 Financial Plan (adopted Apr 1, 2026) (opens in a new tab) pp. 21, 42 and 46
- 2025 Audited Financial Statements (opens in a new tab) p. 24
- 2022 Audited Financial Statements (opens in a new tab) p. 20
- 2025–2029 Financial Plan (opens in a new tab) p. 69, note 5
- Regular Council minutes, Feb 8, 2023 (opens in a new tab) p. 10
- Regular Council agenda, Mar 12, 2025 (staff report: 2150 Island Highway West tree permit) (opens in a new tab) pp. 240–243
- Regular Council minutes, Mar 12, 2025 (Resolution 25-062) (opens in a new tab) p. 6
- Regular Council agenda, Apr 16, 2025 (correspondence log) (opens in a new tab) p. 33
- Regular Council agenda, Mar 25, 2026 (status of Council resolutions) (opens in a new tab) p. 220
- Tree Protection Bylaw No. 725, 2023 (opens in a new tab) ss. 4.2, 4.3, 6
- Town of Qualicum Beach: Tree removal permits (opens in a new tab)
Last checked October 13, 2026. Report a mistake.