About this site
A plain record of what Qualicum Beach Council decided about community funding, built entirely from the Town’s own public documents so anyone can check it.
Who made this
Let Them Eat Golf is researched, written and published by Saleem Barnard, a Kwalikum Secondary School graduate and local shop owner who lives in Qualicum Beach, as a personal, non-commercial project. The site is independent and is not affiliated with the Town of Qualicum Beach. Read my story in Neighbours of Qualicum Beach.
Just the facts. This site is not paid for, sponsored or authorized by any candidate, party or campaign.
The facts are presented as neutrally as we can: what was asked, what was decided, and the reason recorded. Where a number could mislead, we say so.
What this covers
One Council, one full term. The same five members took office at the inaugural meeting of November 7, 2022 and have served together since. British Columbia holds general local elections every four years on the third Saturday of October, so this term ends with the vote on October 17, 2026.
This site began as a record of January 2025 onward, which is the midpoint of the term. It now covers the whole of it, so the 2023 and 2024 decisions can be read beside the ones that followed.
How this was compiled
- All 63 sets of Council minutes the Town has posted for 2023 and 2024, plus the 2023–2027 and 2024–2028 Financial Plans and the 2023 and 2024 Annual Reports.
- Minutes of 60 Council meetings (January 2025 to July 31, 2026) and 20 Committee of the Whole meetings.
- The staff reports and scoping sheets that state the amounts requested.
- For September 9, 2026, the agenda and the Town’s Council Corner summary, because the minutes are not yet posted.
- For what Council did fund and who it hired: the Statements of Financial Information for 2022 to 2025 (every supplier paid more than $25,000; 2023 is a scan, read from the page images), the 2026–2030 Financial Plan and the 2025 Annual Report and Financial Statements.
- All from the Town’s public document library at qualicumbeach.com.
- Event dates on the event sponsorships page are checked against organizers’ own pages and local news, linked there.
“Times at Council” counts only public Council and Committee of the Whole meetings where the item came up. It does not count other committees or informal contact with staff.
Individual members of community groups are not named on this site. Council members are named because their votes are public record.
For the wonks: what that actually involved
People ask how much of this was read, so here is the count.
- 143 sets of meeting minutes — 80 from January 2025 on, and all 63 the Town has posted for 2023 and 2024 — plus the agendas and staff reports attached to them. These are not short. The four agenda packages carrying the Eaglecrest decisions run 176, 224, 275 and 433 pages (September 9, 2026; October 22, 2025; June 18, 2025; March 25, 2026). The decision itself is usually one paragraph somewhere inside.
- 70 source documents are cited by name and linked from the sources page: minutes, agendas, staff reports, bylaws, financial plans, annual reports, audited statements and media releases.
- 4 hours and 3 minutes of hearing video. The October 6, 2025 rezoning hearing ran 2:00 pm to 6:03 pm. We watched the 3 hours and 4 minutes of public comment (34:46 to 3:39:00) and coded every speaker: what they led with, and what else they raised. That is where the 34-to-4 count on the Eaglecrest page comes from. The minutes record 47 speaking turns by about 40 people; we counted 42 distinct speakers on video and say so.
- The Town’s own survey, all 902 responses. 891 answered the first question, 835 gave their age. We read the published long answers, not just the percentages.
- Freedom-of-information records from ten requests we did not file, all published by Town Hall Math: among them the purchase agreement, the donation agreement, the seller’s appraisal, the building condition assessment, negotiation emails and payment records. We read each one page by page before citing it.
- Outside data where the Town has none: the 2021 Census profile for Qualicum Beach, the Town’s 2026 tax rate (Bylaw 922), the Altus 2025 Canadian Cost Guide, Vancouver Island Real Estate Board benchmark prices, Statistics Canada construction-employment multipliers, Job Bank wage medians, and a 2025 JAMA Network Open study. Every estimate built from these is labelled “our estimate” and shows its inputs.
- The Town’s development tracker, which lists every development application since 2019 with its current status. That is how we checked whether an application Council refused or postponed ever came back. The minutes alone do not say.
- 5,490 lines of checked data behind 73 pages. Totals are computed from that data, never typed in by hand, so a corrected figure corrects everywhere at once — and the downloadable summary and spreadsheet are generated from the same data, so they cannot disagree with the site.
How it was built. The reading, cross-checking and drafting were done with Claude Code, Anthropic’s command-line coding agent, running the Claude Opus 5 model. The corrections below are what happened when that checking caught something. If a number here is wrong, the document beside it will show it.
Other people’s work
Town Hall Math is a separate, independent project about the Eaglecrest purchase. It is not connected to this site, and neither of us worked on the other’s.
It tells the story of that purchase far better than we do. If you want to understand how $8.5 million became a $21.2 million project, read it there first. This site is the wider ledger: what else Council said no to over the same period, and what it cost.
Town Hall Math has also filed freedom-of-information requests and published what came back. Records from ten of those requests are cited on this site and credited where we use them: on the Eaglecrest page, the home page and in our fact checks. One of them, the Memorial Golf Club’s financial statements, was obtained by a local resident; Town Hall Math publishes it with permission. None is in the Town’s document library. We read each document ourselves before citing it. Everything else on this site is compiled from the Town’s own public records and the other sources named on each page.
Summary (PDF, 93 KB) Full spreadsheet (Excel, 37 KB)
See the full list of source documents.
Council, 2022–2026 term
- Mayor Teunis Westbroek
- Councillor Scott Harrison
- Councillor Anne Skipsey
- Councillor Petronella Vander Valk
- Councillor Jean Young
All five were sworn in at the inaugural meeting of November 7, 2022 and none has been replaced since. The term ends with the general local election on October 17, 2026.
Minutes record how each member voted, but rarely why. The debate itself is on the Town’s YouTube channel.
What we couldn’t find
- September 9, 2026 votes are not yet public.
- The Old School House request was also discussed in a closed meeting (July 9, 2025). That discussion is not public.
- No follow-up was found for the Hamilton Marsh motion, the lawn bowling roof assessment, or Eaglecrest land-sale revenue.
- The Seaside Cruizers Father’s Day Show & Shine received $2,000 (May 13, 2026, 4–1, Young opposed). Staff recommended $2,500, but the amount requested is not in the minutes, so it is not in the underfunded list. It is on the event sponsorships page.
- What the Town paid any of its Eaglecrest advisors, and a breakdown of the $166,842 spent on due diligence in 2025. See Consultants, lawyers and contractors.
- What some payments were for: Dalelynn, HBR and Deloitte, and two payments to groups (Into the Woods Child Care in 2023, Island Crisis Care in 2025).
- Which approved event sponsorships have been paid. Payments that small aren’t in the Town’s yearly supplier lists.
- Capital projects reprioritized to pay for the $2,581,000 Seacrest Place slope stabilization (January 22, 2025) are not itemized in the minutes.
Looked at, but not counted
- Skatepark (March 4, 2026). A defeated motion would have cut the skatepark fountain and washroom from $60,000 to $30,000. Its defeat kept full funding.
- Seniors’ Centre space (September 9, 2026). Council invited the Centre to request subsidized space before the 2027 budget. No request was refused.
- Community Park facility and community gardens. Both have been scheduled for 2028 since 2023, so they were not pushed back.
- Bus garage, pickleball courts (Town share) and public works workplace. Pushed back in July 2025, then restored.
Corrections
If you find a mistake, email facts@LetThemEatGolf.ca with a link to the document that shows it. We will fix it and list the correction here, with the date.
Candidates’ right to reply. On September 23, 2026, we wrote to every candidate we fact-checked, using the same message and the same deadline. We invited each one to point out any fact we got wrong and to send a record that shows it. When a record proves us wrong, we fix the page and list the change below. When a candidate disagrees with how we read the facts but can’t show the facts are wrong, we may publish their short response word for word, labelled as theirs. Our finding stays unless the facts change. We check what candidates send us against the Town’s records, the same way we checked their original statements.
- October 5, 2026: Old asbestos-cement pipe and the law. The water pipes page said nothing requires the Town to dig up abandoned pipe. That was too broad. WorkSafeBC lets old pipe stay in the ground if it is on the Town’s asbestos list, but old pipe that a dig uncovers and that is breaking down must be removed or sealed. The page now says so, and adds a section on PFAS. The Oak fact check now answers whether the Town charges landing fees: it stopped in 2021. A new page covers the airport’s costs, grants and noise.
- October 2, 2026: The Town’s reply on the economic development strategy. Luke Sales, the Town’s Director of Planning, replied on October 1 to our letter of September 29. He said the report will be made available before Council’s 2027 strategic planning, and gave no date. The Eaglecrest page quotes the reply in full, and the podcast episode The Golf Course was re-recorded to include it.
- October 2, 2026: Pickleball, golfers and Eaglecrest. The pickleball request and the podcast episode Pickled quoted the Mayor saying golfers had “contributed millions onto the golf course” without checking it. We have now. The Memorial Golf Club’s audited statements show about $2.2 million of equipment and improvements bought under its lease, from green fees and dues, and $2 million of Town reserves spent first on its clubhouse and maintenance facility, repaid without interest at $85,000 a year. Both pages now say so, and that no golf group was asked to share the cost of Eaglecrest. The Memorial page adds the clubhouse figures and the 1981 purchase. The episode was re-recorded with these changes.
- October 1, 2026: Donald Couzens’s pickleball claim. His claim that the pickleball club offered to fully fund converting a tennis court is now Misleading, not Inaccurate. We said we found no such offer. There was one: on May 27, 2026 the club told Council it had a quotation of $60,000 to $100,000 for the conversion and would put in $100,000, “so we would cover the whole thing.” We found it in the meeting video while making a podcast episode; the minutes record it too. The rest of his claim still needs context: nothing has been built near the airport, and the Town’s share there depends on the club’s. The pickleball request now includes the offer, the history of the cost estimates and the tennis club’s position.
- September 29, 2026: The restaurant lease. The Eaglecrest page now sets out the clubhouse restaurant lease, released under freedom of information: the rent per square foot next to local asking rents, what the Town puts in, and a clause that ends the lease if no golf course agreement was signed by July 1, 2026.
- September 29, 2026: A shorter home page. The home page had grown to cover everything. What Council did fund, consultants, lawyers and contractors, and the Memorial Golf Course each have their own page now. What they say is unchanged.
- September 29, 2026: More freedom-of-information records. We read the rest of the
records Town Hall Math has published, and added what they show.
- Corrections: amounts we listed as “Not published” for Keso, MODUS and the restaurant lease now show the released figures. The Memorial Golf Club’s financial statements, which we said weren’t public, were released to a resident. The MODUS feasibility study was released, with its financial figures blacked out.
- New on the Eaglecrest page: the seller, not the Town, hired the appraiser behind the $12.98 million value; talks went on after the Town’s February 2025 “no further offers” release; the first Council-endorsed purchase agreement dates from March 2024; the course contract grew to $1,448,036; and Council removed the purchase conditions five days after staff said the Phase I environmental study was still to come.
- On the home page, the Memorial club’s finances and bridge repayment terms. In our fact checks, the only record the Town found on the second course’s effect on Memorial.
- September 29, 2026: The purchase agreement. Our Eaglecrest page said the purchase agreement’s terms had not been published. Town Hall Math has since obtained it through freedom of information and published it. We read all 17 pages and now summarize what it says. The seller agreed to sell only if the price reflected the land’s value once rezoned. The Town paid the full $8.5 million on closing, with no money held back. The seller’s promise that it caused no contamination continues after the sale, but the agreement has no separate environmental guarantee. The Town still has not published the agreement.
- September 29, 2026: The economic development strategy. Staff reported the Town’s economic development strategy complete in September 2026, but it hasn’t been published. We wrote to the Town asking it to publish the strategy before advance voting. The Eaglecrest page has the details and the letter.
- September 29, 2026: Anne Skipsey’s reply. Skipsey wrote to us about five of our findings, and we have added her words to each. Her claim that the Island Highway apartments show how quickly a development can be approved is now Accurate, not Misleading: the earlier refusal doesn’t change her point. She agreed the land was bought for $85,000 an acre, with $65,000 the Town’s cost after the donation, so that claim is now marked corrected. We also removed our figure of about $108,000 for each acre the Town can sell, because the golf course acres won’t be sold either. Her tree bylaw and Memorial Golf Club claims stay Misleading.
- September 29, 2026: Anne Skipsey’s FireSmart claim and website. Skipsey pointed us to a presentation at the September 9, 2026 Council meeting. On the Town’s video, the Brown Property Preservation Society president says volunteers and Parks staff cleared fire fuel within about 30 metres of the Palm Drive homes in 2022 and 2023. Her FireSmart claim is now Accurate, not Not verified. She has also changed her website to say the $65,000 an acre is after the donation, so that claim is now marked corrected.
- September 27, 2026: Event sponsorship totals. The home page said $17,984 went to 10 events. That is the amount approved. Groups are paid only after they send receipts, and in April 2026 the Qualicum Beach Collective still hadn’t sent them for its $800 Moonlight Madness I-Spy grant. The home page now says “approved”, and a new event sponsorships page covers every application, vote and what happened next.
- September 27, 2026: What Council did fund, and who it hired. The site covered what Council refused. The home page now also shows what Council did fund: yearly partners like the museum and the Chamber, larger payments to groups, event sponsorships and property tax breaks. It also lists consultants, lawyers and contractors, starting with Eaglecrest. The nav link “Underfunded” is now “Funding”.
- September 27, 2026: Mischa Oak’s tree bylaw claim. A reader pointed out that we hadn’t checked what Oak says about the Tree Protection Bylaw. We have added it as Misleading. The bylaw adds permits and costs, but it has a permit for trees that are a fire hazard to property, and most homeowners can remove one protected tree every two years without a permit. Oak wrote to us about it, and we added his response and the full permit costs.
- September 25, 2026: Adam Walker’s correspondence log claim. His promise to bring back public access to letters is now Accurate, not Not verified. While researching his time on Council, we found that Council’s correspondence logs, until May 2023, said the letters could be read in a binder at the Town Hall information counter. By June 2023 that note was gone. We had said we found no record either way.
- September 23, 2026: School of Dance. The Qualicum Beach School of Dance has moved out of Qualicum Commons. The Commons page now shows it crossed out of the tenant list.
- September 23, 2026: Qualicum Commons petition. The Commons page gave only the early count of nearly 1,400 signatures, from April. The petition now has 2,837, and the page says so.
- September 21, 2026: Saahtlam Park’s name. The playground page said Qualicum First Nation gifted the name in 2023. Council adopted the name on September 28, 2022.
- September 21, 2026: Adam Walker’s fact check. Walker wrote to us about four items. We
checked each against his full answers and the Town’s records.
- Eagle Park is now Accurate, not Inaccurate. We had read “that opportunity was missed” as saying the FireSmart work wasn’t done. In his full answer the missed opportunity is the public education, not the work.
- Borrowing is now Accurate, not Inaccurate. The Town can borrow about $25 million without elector approval, but about half is already committed, so borrowing on the scale of Eaglecrest would need it. That approval can come from an alternative approval process rather than a vote.
- Eaglecrest information is now Accurate, not Misleading. The Town has published yearly totals, but not the detail he names: expected revenue by lot, the density options or servicing costs.
- Correspondence log is now Not verified, not Inaccurate. Walker says he means public access to the letters themselves, kept upstairs at Town Hall before meetings. We found no record of that either way. The log itself is still on every agenda.
- September 21, 2026: Scott Harrison’s fact check. His claim that Council rejected two duplexes is now Accurate, not Inaccurate. Harrison pointed us to 441 Memorial Avenue. It was a two-lot subdivision, not a duplex, but it would have added one home, and together with 365 First Avenue West it bears out his point. The minutes still give no density reason.
- September 21, 2026: Mischa Oak’s fact check. We checked three items against the Town’s
documents again.
- Asset planning is now Accurate, not Misleading. The Town has no public long-term plan for replacing its infrastructure: the detailed replacement plan was shown to Council only as slides, and the Town’s budget lists the long-term plans as still to come. We had also said the Town’s asset management policy dates from 2020. It dates from 2016.
- Public input is now Accurate, not Inaccurate. This Council kept the rule against spoken comments at Council meetings, never voted on bringing them back and dropped a review it had scheduled. The rule itself dates from 2020, under the previous Council.
- Consultants is still Accurate. We no longer say half of his $2 million went to one engineering firm, because we can’t tell what his figure includes. We added the 2025 figures.
- September 20, 2026: The first half of the term. The site used to start in January 2025.
It now covers the whole term, back to the inaugural meeting of November 7, 2022, using the Town’s 2023 and 2024
minutes, financial plans and annual reports.
- Two funding decisions from 2023 have been added: the Oceanside Community Track, cut from $71,200 to $18,600, and the Nanaimo Rent Bank, where the money was struck out of the motion. The rent bank is listed for the record but not counted as a local group, because a councillor brought the motion rather than the society applying.
- Seven Town projects closed, narrowed or held at the December 11, 2024 meeting have been added. That meeting set the 2025–2029 Financial Plan, seven months before the Eaglecrest funding plan existed, and it is where several of the projects later moved by that plan were first scheduled.
- A new section on the home page (now its own page) records what Council put into the Qualicum Beach Memorial Golf Course in 2023 and 2024 — $431,000 in grants and waived fees, plus a loan of up to $350,000. That is a different course from Eaglecrest, on land the Town has owned for decades, and the section says so.
- A motion on November 8, 2023 to defer all land-use planning work to “2027 or beyond” failed 3–2, with the Mayor and Councillor Vander Valk in favour. It is recorded here because it failed, not because it passed.
- Three requests that were already on the site turn out to be older than it showed. Pickleball starts in March 2023, not July 2025: Council budgeted $170,000 for courts in April 2023, $85,000 of it from the same Growing Communities grant later moved to Eaglecrest, and nothing was built. The Biosphere Society’s rent was set at $2,000 a month in a closed meeting in October 2024, which is where the $24,000 a year it later asked to have reduced comes from. The Old School House lease and fee-for-service proposal was before Council in November 2024 and held to fall 2025.
- Lost growth gains three items from 2023 and 2024, found by checking the Town’s development tracker against the minutes: 1085 Ravensbourne Lane (46 homes, postponed in July 2024 and still in staff review), 3022 Island Highway West (a variance refused 4–1 in September 2024 and a smaller version approved in April 2026, so we count 19 months of tax, not every year), and 441 Memorial Avenue (a two-lot subdivision that needed 10 centimetres of lot frontage; the motion to grant it died for want of a seconder).
- On Ravensbourne we say plainly what the other lost-growth items do not have to: staff recommended the postponement, Council was unanimous, and the application was incomplete. It is on the list because the homes are not built and the file has not moved, not because Council went against its planners.
- September 20, 2026: Credit to Town Hall Math. We checked this site against
Town Hall Math, an independent project on the same purchase, to be sure we
had not used its work without saying so. We had not: every figure here already traced to a Town document, the
meeting video, the Census, the Town’s water report, news reports or B.C. legislation. The $12.98 million appraisal
and the $4.48 million tax receipt on our Eaglecrest page come from the Town’s own
September 14, 2026 FAQ, p. 4.
- We have since added two records that Town Hall Math obtained through freedom of information and published, and that the Town has not: the donation agreement and the August 2025 building condition assessment. Both are credited on the Eaglecrest page, and we read both before citing them.
- The bullet on the purchase agreement now notes the June 26, 2025 contract date and the confidentiality clause. The bullet on the 40-acre park now states what the donation agreement requires: the forested land kept as park and habitat in perpetuity, with a conservation covenant registered within a month of subdividing. How much of it was already covenanted, and who pays for its upkeep, are still unanswered.
- September 19, 2026: A check of every request. After the Old School House correction, we
checked all 14 requests against the Town’s documents again. For requests with no end date, we now count the first
year, the same way for everyone.
- St. Stephen’s asked for $20,000 a year, not $100,000. We missed a one-time $10,000 grant on December 10, 2025, so the request moves from Declined to Cut. We also withdrew our suggestion of a minutes error.
- The Biosphere Society asked for $1-a-year rent with no end date; the $120,000 was our own five-year calculation.
- For pickleball, the club proposed a Town share of $85,000. The $125,000 was Council’s own offer.
- The Legion and the School District named no amount. The figures shown are a Town budget and the fees already paid, and are now labelled that way.
- The Community Movement page stated as fact that ParticipACTION sponsored the event. The Collective disputed that.
- Staff did give a reason on Hamilton Marsh, and the Town completed the Eaglecrest purchase in December 2025, not July.
- We also added missing meetings and votes on several pages.
- September 18, 2026: The Old School House. We said TOSH asked for $504,000. That figure came from a staff scoping sheet showing its proposed agreement rising each year, from $75,000 in 2026 to $115,000 in 2030. TOSH’s own proposal asked for “$75,000 annually” with no end date. The request page now counts the $29,000 it asked for in 2025 plus $75,000 for 2026: $104,000 in total. Totals across the site went down by $400,000. We also added a July 23, 2025 Council meeting and the February 11, 2026 vote that paid out the $50,000.
Last checked October 13, 2026.