Where the money went: Eaglecrest Golf Course

Council bought Eaglecrest Golf Course for $8.5 million. With course work, land servicing and neighbourhood work, the Town’s project budget is now $21,199,800.

What residents told Council

On October 6, 2025, Council held a public hearing on rezoning the Eaglecrest land. More than 40 people spoke. 34 opposed the rezoning. 4 supported it, and 4 did not address it.

The hearing was held on a Monday afternoon, from 2:00 pm to 6:03 pm. People could also send written submissions until the hearing closed. Watch the hearing on the Town’s YouTube channel.

The most common worry was what would be built: more density, taller buildings and a changed neighbourhood. Many also said the process was moving too fast, with a tight deadline and information missing. Others raised the forest, wildlife and flood spillway, traffic, and the risk that costs go beyond the $8.5 million purchase.

Concerns of the 34 speakers who opposed the rezoning
ConcernMain reason forAlso raised by
Density, height, neighbourhood character 11 13
Forest, wildlife, flood spillway 5 6
Property values and views 4 3
Process: speed, deadline, missing information 3 9
Traffic and safety 3 6
Financial risk beyond $8.5 million 2 4
Town acting as both developer and regulator 2 1
Infrastructure and health (asbestos pipes, pesticides) 2 0
East/west imbalance 1 6
Commercial use at Eaglecrest Dr / Country Club Dr 1 8
No affordable or workforce housing in the plan 0 1
Speakers opposed34

All 4 supporters said public ownership is better than private development. Several also said they trust Council and staff, and that this is a rare chance to fix a neglected course and closed clubhouse.

How this was counted: from the meeting video (public comments, 34:46 to 3:39:00). Times and the written submissions are from the Town’s hearing notice and minutes. Each speaker has one main reason, the one they led with or spent the most time on. “Also raised by” counts speakers who mentioned it beyond their main reason. The video’s captions were generated automatically and may contain errors.

What the Town’s survey asked

Before the purchase was final, the Town ran an online survey, open September 9 to 28, 2025. 902 people started it. Its first question was: What do you think about the Town’s proposal to acquire the Eaglecrest lands?

The only answers offered, and how many chose each (891 answered)
AnswerSharePeople
Excited about the acquisition opportunity 65.8% 586
Unsure / I don’t know 11.8% 105
Concerned about the acquisition opportunity 22.5% 200

There was no option to say the Town should not buy. None of the survey’s questions or answer options mentioned the $8.5 million price, where the money would come from, the effect on taxes, or the risks. Nor did they mention the community projects pushed back to pay for it, which Council had approved on July 23, about seven weeks before the survey opened. The only money question asked which amenities or improvements the Town should consider in a funding plan.

On October 22, 2025, staff told Council the survey showed an overall positive view from respondents regarding the potential acquisition itself, citing the 65.8% who were excited.

Younger residents were missing from the survey. Of the 835 people who gave their age, none were under 25, 8% were under 45, and 63% were 65 or older. About 11% of the Town’s residents are under 25.

Anyone with the link could respond, and 11% said they live outside Qualicum Beach. The Town published every written answer, including those that called the survey biased or asked why there was no way to say no.

Sources: the Town’s survey results and written answers, and the October 22, 2025 Council agenda (staff memo). The text shown to respondents before the first question could not be recovered; the survey link is now closed.

Where the $8.5 million came from

As approved by Council on July 23, 2025.

Purchase funded from
SourceAmountWhat it was for
Growing Communities Fund (provincial grant)Provincial grant rules $2,000,000 One-time 2023 grant from the Province ($3,346,000) for community infrastructure and amenities. Had been set for Saahtlam Park, pickleball courts, the bus garage and workplace modernization. $41,597 left at the end of 2025.
General Fund accumulated surplus $1,275,000 General-purpose surplus. No repayment is scheduled.
Qualicum Beach Land Reserve Fund $1,200,000 Land.
Open-space development cost chargesRestricted by law $700,000 Paid by developers. Can only pay for park and open-space capital.
Community amenity contributions $650,000 Paid by developers for community amenities. The Town says this included the $450,000 Affordable Housing Reserve.
Strategic Initiatives Reserve $400,000 The fund most community requests draw from. $400,000 was approved; the Town’s 2025 records show $542,000 borrowed.
Park Land Reserve FundRestricted by law $275,000 Cash in lieu of park land. Can only be used to buy park land.
Subtotal: existing reserves, surplus and grant$6,500,000
Future sale of Town-owned land$2,000,000Not yet received.
Total purchase price$8,500,000

What the public hasn’t seen

  • The environmental reports. Before buying, the Town had Phase I and II environmental reports and a desktop ecological report done. None has been published. A Phase II usually means soil or water samples were taken. The purchase could not close until the Town was satisfied with the land’s environmental condition. On October 22, 2025, staff told Council the Phase I study was still Anticipated October 2025. Five days later, in a closed meeting, Council removed the last conditions and went ahead. The Town has not said whether Council saw the study first. Staff’s June 2025 list of risks had eight headings, and none mentions the environment. (Town FAQ, Sep 14, 2026, p. 3; Purchase and sale agreement, s. 3.1(a), released under FOI-2026-38; Oct 22, 2025 Council agenda, p. 82; Nov 20, 2025 Council agenda, p. 67, Oct 27 closed-meeting motion; June 3, 2025 in-camera staff report, pp. 41–42, released under FOI-2026-33; all FOI records published by Town Hall Math)
  • The purchase agreement. The Town has not published it. A copy was released in September 2026 under a freedom-of-information request, after a review by the Information and Privacy Commissioner. The Town signed it on June 26, 2025. The seller agreed to sell on the condition that the Purchase Price take into account the value of the Lands once rezoned, and the sale could not go ahead unless the land was rezoned for housing by November 1, 2025, a condition that may not be waived. The Town paid the full $8.5 million on closing, with no money held back. The seller promised that it had not caused or allowed any contamination while it owned the land and knew of none, and that promise continues after the sale. There is no separate environmental guarantee: the only claims the seller agreed to cover are about the tax receipt and any real estate commission. (Purchase and sale agreement, recital E and ss. 2.2, 3.1(c), 5.4, 6.1(h), 6.3 and 7.4, released under FOI-2026-38 and published by Town Hall Math)
  • The building condition assessment. The Town had the clubhouse, pro shop and maintenance buildings inspected in August 2025, before the sale closed, and did not publish the report. A 98-page copy was released in August 2026 after a review by the Information and Privacy Commissioner. The inspector priced repairs section by section, warned readers to be prepared for costs that could potentially be 5 to 10 times more, and listed materials that may contain asbestos as needing a separate survey. (Pacific West Building Inspections, Property Condition Assessment, Report 6861-2025, August 20, 2025, released under FOI-2026-33 and published by Town Hall Math)
  • How much of the 40-acre park was already protected. Before the purchase, the Town said about 25 acres of the private golf land were limited to golf course use by a covenant “outside of the Town’s control.” In October 2025 it said the park went on the east side partly because some of that land is “subject to an existing covenant preventing development.” It has not said how much of the 40 acres was already protected. The donation agreement requires the Town to keep the forested “B Lands” as public park and habitat in perpetuity, and to register a conservation covenant against title within a month of subdividing. It does not say how much of that land was already covenanted, or who pays to look after it. (Town letter to Eaglecrest residents, Oct 24, 2024; Town FAQ, Oct 31, 2025, p. 6; Donation agreement, s. 7.1(f)–(g), released under FOI-2026-24 and published by Town Hall Math)
  • When talks began. The owners’ agent approached Town staff in 2023. The agent had told the owners there was no development potential under the Town’s land-use rules. Council first discussed buying the course in a closed meeting on April 19, 2023. In February 2024 staff gave Council a table titled Eaglecrest Low-impact Upzoning Potential. It listed six sites that could be rezoned for housing, one of them Town-owned land on Fairways Drive. In March 2024 staff sent the owners a purchase agreement which has received endorsement from our Council. (Town memos and emails, pp. 1, 12–14 and 64, released under FOI-2026-42 and published by Town Hall Math)
  • What the seller got. In February 2025 the Town said the owners had turned down its offers and it would make “no further offers.” Talks went on. On March 6, staff wrote to the owners: We will be bringing your offer to Council next week. In April, staff told them Council had directed staff to provide an offer to you. By May 2, staff were offering $8.5 million in cash. Council agreed to pay $8.5 million, about 2.5 times the land’s 2024 appraised value of $3.41 million. The Town said the price reflected the land’s “rezoning potential,” which only the Town could deliver. After the Town rezoned the land, it was appraised at $12.98 million, and the Town gave the seller a tax receipt for the $4.48 million difference as a gift. The receipt lowers the seller’s income tax, so that part is paid by federal and provincial taxpayers rather than the Town. (Town release, Feb 13, 2025; Town FAQ, Oct 31, 2025, p. 5; Town FAQ, Sep 14, 2026, p. 4; Purchase and sale agreement, recital E, released under FOI-2026-38; Town emails, pp. 38, 42 and 47, released under FOI-2026-42; both published by Town Hall Math)
  • The $12.98 million appraisal. The seller hired the appraiser, not the Town. The report was written for the purpose of asset valuation, and reliance on it is strictly limited to Semiahmoo Golf Centre Ltd. It valued the land on December 1, 2025, the day the sale closed. The Town then used the report for the $4.48 million tax receipt. Most of the value, $8.88 million, is on the 8.9 acres the Town rezoned for housing. The 52-acre golf course is valued at $2.59 million, and the 43 acres of park at $1.51 million. The appraiser assumed the Town will keep the new zoning, and that the soil is clean: no soil surveys, environmental studies, or property condition assessments were provided or undertaken. (Wong & Liu Valuation Group appraisal, January 7, 2026, pp. 2, 7, 10 and 67, released under FOI-2026-37 and published by Town Hall Math)
  • Any study of golf’s value to tourism. When Council gave the Eaglecrest bylaws first reading on September 17, 2025, the staff resolution said the course lands provide employment opportunities and contribute to local tourism. No study was cited, and we found none in Town records (see also the Town’s economic development strategy, below). At the same meeting the Parksville Qualicum Beach Tourism Association gave its annual report: $209 million in visitor spending in 2024 and 10% of the region’s jobs. It gave no figures for golf, and no councillor asked. (Sep 17, 2025 Council agenda, p. 3; meeting video, from 9:30)
  • The Town’s economic development strategy. In March 2025 Council hired the consultant Nordicity for $112,470 to write a sustainable economic development strategy. A $100,000 provincial grant paid for most of it. Its first phase was a tourism and retail gap analysis. On September 9, 2026, staff listed the project as 100% complete: The report is complete and recommendations will be considered by Council in Strategic Planning 2027. That will be the next Council. Neither the strategy nor the gap analysis is on the Town’s project page or in its document library, and the project page still says the strategy would go to Council in February 2026. (Mar 12, 2025 Council minutes, Resolution 25-061; Oct 21, 2024 Committee of the Whole agenda; Town project page; Sep 9, 2026 Council agenda, p. 132)
    On September 29, 2026, I wrote to the Town’s Chief Administrative Officer, with copies to Mayor and Council and the Director of Planning, asking the Town to publish the strategy and its supporting reports before advance voting begins on October 7. (Read the letter: web page, PDF)
    On October 1, 2026, Luke Sales, the Town’s Director of Planning, replied: The Sustainable Economic Development Strategy report will be discussed during the Town’s 2027 strategic planning process so that Council can consider the recommendations and determine whether resources should be allocated to their implementation. The report will be made available in advance of that process to allow both Council and the public time to review and consider its recommendations. The reply does not give a date for publishing the report.
  • Drainage. After deciding to buy, the Town found “extensive, unknown irrigation and drainage deficiencies in the golf course.” It dug a large new pond that was not in the original plan. The budget also holds a $1 million placeholder for drainage improvements. The $1,181,800 course contract had grown to $1,448,036 by July 2026. The changes added $80,000 to dig a pond and $174,465 to dredge it. They also took out $247,693 of irrigation materials, which the Town bought itself. A separate $470,000 budget for irrigation parts, pumps, tree work and consultants had $17,184 left. Speakers at the hearing asked whether part of the land is a flood spillway. We found no Town document that answers this. (Town FAQ, Sep 14, 2026, p. 6; Sep 9, 2026 Council agenda, p. 135; Town payment records, pp. 22 and 134–135, released under FOI-2026-54 and published by Town Hall Math)
  • Pesticides. The Town’s pesticide bylaw bans pesticides on lawns and turf on Town land, except Memorial Golf Course and Eaglecrest’s 17th fairway, the part the Town already owned and leased to the course. The Town now owns the whole course. The bylaw has not been changed, and the Town has not said whether the ban now applies there. Separately, the Town tests its Berwick wells for pesticides “due to nearby golf course activities.” Those wells are on Memorial Avenue, about 3 km from Eaglecrest, beside a different golf course. (Pesticide Use Bylaw No. 650, p. 2; 2025 Annual Water Report, p. 4; BC well records)

Why it matters

In BC, the current owner of contaminated land is responsible for cleaning it up, even if someone else caused the contamination. The owner can sue past owners to recover the cost, unless a contract says otherwise. (Environmental Management Act, s. 45–47; J.I. Properties v. PPG, 2015 BCCA 472)

Land for housing must meet stricter soil standards than a golf course. When Ottawa’s Kanata Lakes golf course was proposed for housing, tests found mercury above the limit, from old fungicides used on the greens. (City of Ottawa) BC courts have also held towns responsible for flooding after they approved development that overloaded the drains.

A 2025 US study found that people living within a mile of a golf course had about twice the odds of getting Parkinson’s disease. The link was strongest where drinking water came from groundwater near a course. The authors say golf course pesticides may play a role but did not prove it. All of Qualicum Beach’s tap water comes from groundwater wells, which the Town describes as deep. It tests one of its two wellfields for pesticides because of golf course activity nearby. That wellfield is about 3 km from Eaglecrest, beside a different golf course, and the Town’s water report does not give the results. (Krzyzanowski et al., JAMA Network Open, 2025; 2025 Annual Water Report, pp. 2, 4)

Publishing the Phase I and II reports and the terms of the purchase would answer most of these questions.

Credit where it is due: the donation agreement and the August 2025 building condition assessment are not in the Town’s document library. They were obtained through freedom-of-information requests by Town Hall Math, a separate independent project, and published there with the Town’s redactions intact. We read both documents ourselves before citing them. Their account of how the purchase happened is better than ours; this page is the money. Everything else here comes from the Town’s own public records, the meeting video, the Census and the sources named above. We also fact-checked the Town’s September 14, 2026 Eaglecrest FAQ against its own records.

What the tags mean

Three of the funds used came with rules set outside Council.

  • Park Land Reserve Fund ($275,000): restricted by law. Money developers pay instead of handing over park land. It can only be used to buy park land. (Community Charter, s. 188–189)
  • Open-space development cost charges ($700,000): restricted by law. Fees on new development for the parks growth needs. Capital costs only, such as buying or improving park land. (Local Government Act, s. 566)
  • Growing Communities Fund ($2,000,000): provincial grant rules. A one-time 2023 grant for community infrastructure and amenities, kept in its own reserve. It can buy land only when the land is needed for an eligible project. The Province has not said whether this use qualifies. (Province of B.C., Growing Communities Fund)

None of this $2,975,000 could have paid grants to community groups. The $2,000,000 grant had been set aside for Saahtlam Park, pickleball courts, the bus garage and a public works building.

The general-purpose money was the $1,275,000 surplus and $400,000 from the Strategic Initiatives Reserve ($1,675,000). Community amenity contributions are negotiated with developers and governed by Town policy.

The full project budget: $21,199,800

From the Town’s budget amendment adopted July 15, 2026 (Bylaw 921.01).

Eaglecrest project budget
ItemBudgetSpent by June 30, 2026
Purchase and work in 2025–26
Purchase and due diligence On this site: Where the money came from, The donation, Due diligence costs $8,625,000 —
Course reconfiguration (par 35) On this site: The course contract, The course advisor $2,600,000 $1,769,100
Rehabilitation: clubhouse ($600,000), equipment ($900,000), maintenance building and rainwater system ($800,000 placeholder) On this site: The equipment purchase, The restaurant lease $2,300,000 $1,148,600
Contingency $1,004,800 $0
Servicing land for sale, phase 1 On this site: The servicing contract, Land sales $800,000 $53,600
Neighbourhood work, 2027 on
Traffic solution, Highway 19A $2,870,000 —
Park improvements $1,000,000 —
Drainage improvements, Eaglecrest neighbourhood On this site: More on drainage $1,000,000 —
Pedestrian improvements $1,000,000 —
Total project budget$21,199,800
  • $12,574,800 of this is beyond the purchase itself. The Town expects land sales to cover it.
  • Not included: $2,863,000 for new water and storm mains on Eaglecrest Drive. They were in this budget until June 2026, when the Town moved them to its asset management reserves. In July it applied for a federal grant of $1,082,000 toward the work.
  • Spending is from the Town’s mid-2026 capital report. The Town estimates about $4.5 million spent in all of 2026.

Paying the reserves back

The Town’s 2026–2030 Financial Plan schedules $5,266,800 back into reserves, half in 2027 and half in 2028. The $1,275,000 of general surplus has no repayment line of its own, but the same plan shows the general surplus rising by $637,500 in each of those years, which would put it back. None of the budget’s land sales go to it: they exactly cover the project’s spending and the repayments below. On October 2, 2026, the Town’s Chief Administrative Officer wrote that staff will propose adding $1,233,200 of land sales before 2027 to repay the surplus.

Scheduled repayments to reserves
ReserveScheduled repaymentNote
Asset Investment Reserve$2,800,000The Town says this repays the $2M grant and $700,000 of development charges.
Land (property) reserve$1,200,000
Strategic Initiatives Reserve$541,800
Affordable Housing Reserve$450,000
Park Land Reserve$275,000
Total scheduled$5,266,800

The budget counts on $17,841,600 from land sales between 2026 and 2028 ($6,824,800 in 2026, $5,483,400 in 2027, $5,533,400 in 2028). As of September 18, 2026, the Town’s records show lots listed or pending listing, but no completed sale.

What is left in the reserves

The Town’s September 2026 FAQ says reserve balances are enough to carry about $4.5 million of Eaglecrest spending in 2026 until land sells. Its own audited statements show what was left at the end of 2025.

Reserve balances at year end
ReserveEnd of 2024End of 2025Note
Strategic Initiatives Reserve $781,995 −$21,200 Overdrawn. The fund most community requests draw from.
Property (land) reserve $1,233,966 $80,374
Growing Communities Fund $3,573,510 $41,597 Provincial grant for infrastructure and amenities.
Affordable housing reserve $450,000 $0
Park land reserve $287,959 $133,038
Asset replacement reserve $5,384,623 $4,364,853 Staff say it is underfunded.
Water infrastructure reserve $2,528,105 $2,798,325 Staff say contributions are too low.
All reserves$18,862,279$11,937,216

What remains is mostly the asset replacement and water reserves, which staff wrote in November 2025 are already short. To be fair, not all of the 2025 drop was Eaglecrest: reserves also paid for other work that year, such as the skatepark.

Sources: 2025 Audited Financial Statements, Note 11 (p. 19); Town FAQ, Sep 14, 2026, p. 5; Committee of the Whole agenda, Nov 12, 2025, p. 52.

The restaurant lease

The Town leases the clubhouse restaurant, bar, banquet hall and kitchen, about 5,700 square feet, to Extreme Eatz Restaurants Inc. The Town chose the company through a request for proposals. The restaurant opened as The Shack Taphouse on June 3, 2026. Council approved the lease in a closed meeting on March 11, 2026, and the Town did not publish it. A copy was released under freedom of information.

Base rent under the lease, plus GST
PeriodPer monthPer yearPer square foot, per year
Opening to Dec 2027 $4,500 $54,000 $9.47
2028 $5,000 $60,000 $10.53
2029 $5,500 $66,000 $11.58
2030 $5,665 $67,980 $11.93

It is a net lease: the tenant also pays property taxes and utilities. The patio is not counted in the square footage and carries no rent. The lease runs to December 31, 2030, and the Town may renew it to 2035.

What the Town puts in

  • No rent until the restaurant opened, or July 1, 2026 at the latest.
  • $180,000 in equipment, furnishings and repairs to the building. The tenant puts in $120,000, which becomes Town property.
  • The Town pays for the structure, roof, heating and cooling, plumbing and electrical. It also pays a growing share of repairs to the kitchen equipment, hood vents, fire suppression, flooring and laundry: 10% in the first year, rising to 65% in the fifth and 90% by the end of a renewal.
  • The rent is flat. It has no share of sales, which some municipal golf restaurant leases include. Section 41 refers to a security deposit, but no clause sets one.

If rent began when the restaurant opened, it adds up to about $279,000 to the end of 2030. After the Town’s $180,000, that leaves about $99,000 over four and a half years, before the Town’s share of repairs.

How the rent compares

The Eaglecrest rent works out to about $9.47 per square foot a year, rising to $11.93. On September 29, 2026, office and retail space in Parksville and Coombs was listed at $12 to $22 per square foot a year, some plus about $4.50 in taxes and building costs. A freestanding office in downtown Qualicum Beach was listed at $3,300 a month for about 1,071 square feet, roughly $37 a square foot. These are asking rents, and a golf clubhouse is a different market: it is seasonal, outside the town centre, and much of the space is a banquet hall. Still, the Town is charging less per square foot than any local listing we found.

For a renewal, the lease requires a site-specific third-party market rental assessment. We found no record of one for the starting rent. The Town has not said how many proposals it received.

The July 1 deadline

The lease says it shall automatically terminate if the Town and the tenant do not sign a lease for the golf course by July 1, 2026. In that case the Town repays the tenant’s improvements, up to $120,000. In March the Town said the golf course agreement was currently being finalized. We found no public record that it was signed, or that the deadline was changed.

Sources: Eaglecrest Golf Course Restaurant Lease, April 2, 2026, ss. 2–10, 18, 21–22, 24(h), 41 and recital C, with the April 14, 2026 amendment, released under FOI-2026-23 and published by Town Hall Math; Town news release, Mar 19, 2026; Town news release, Jun 3, 2026; Jun 24, 2026 Council agenda, closed-meeting motions; listings by Kristie Haz (page 1, page 2, page 3) and Miller Real Estate Team (MLS 1040490).

For comparison

Eaglecrest next to what was turned down or delayed

Eaglecrest was also cited directly as a reason for two community requests (pickleball funding and staff time for the Community Cup co-application) and for delaying the tree protection bylaw.

Sources